So I’m reading this book, Musicophilia: Tales of Music and the Brain, and the chapter I’m on is about amusia. Amusia means “without music.” It’s like color blindness, but for sound. Now I’m sure your thoughts jumped right to that old lady in church who can’t sing in tune to save her life (yet she sings louder than everyone else and always seems to be seated next to you)…yeah, we all know that lady. But tone deafness doesn’t even begin to cover it. These people actually cannot distinguish melodies, pitches, timbres, tones or rhythms. If you played Ravel’s “Bolero”, Ray Charles’ “Shake Your Tail Feather”, Celine Dion’s “I Will Go On” and Marylin Manson’s “Beautiful People” they would not be able to tell them apart. It’s all just noise. Some with amusia describe music as nothing more than pots and pans clanging together with no discernible cohesion.
Strange, isn’t it? To realize how dependent we are on the interpretive power of our brains. Even if the music being played is the most orderly, beautiful, sweet sound in the world, if our brains can’t interpret the sounds then all we perceive is meaningless noise no different than a blender or jackhammer. Or maybe it’s the other way around…maybe music is a bunch of meaningless noises until our brains interpret them as having structure and meaning and emotional content. The ability to order and reorder information is usually an attribute we give to our evolved senses, like speech and social development. So my musings of late have been on the possible evolutionary advantages of music.
Why did our brains evolve with the ability to perceive music? Why do we have such great musical memories? Why do we universally associate musical characteristics with emotions (major keys are happy, minor keys are sad, slow tempos are somber, fast tempos are jubilant, etc.)? In short, why don’t we all have amusia? I came up with a few ideas…not scholarly ones, but they make sense to me.
What if music WAS an evolutionary adaptation as important as language because it WAS a language? Archeological evidence shows that music was around before written language and developed almost in tandem with spoken language. In an experiment explained here, a group of people who could not communicate with language were quickly able to do so with melodies. Parents around the globe communicate with newborns through song, then through vocal variations more resembling speech with toddlers, and finally through speech when the child is able to understand. I certainly do this with Finn. We also see this primordial need for music today reflected in, ironically enough, our super-technological modes of communication.
For instance…have you ever watched the news feed on the Facebook wall of someone who is going through a breakup only to see that they are posting sad song after sad song? They’re trying to share how they FEEL and can’t put it into words adequately without the emotional content of music behind it. Or how about seeing folks post touching YouTube videos about bullying or saving animals or helping starving children? Many don’t have spoken words at all…just images and music (usually soft piano music). Why? Because they only care about making an emotional impact.
Or have you ever been misunderstood online because someone read an unintended emotion into your words? If you could set those words to music there would be no doubt as to your intention. Words can only have an emotional impact if you comprehend what is being said and interpret it correctly…music can transcend language barriers and convey feelings, if not content. What does this have to do with evolution, you ask?
Imagine that you’re one of the first humans and that your tribe encounters another. You don’t speak the same language so you can’t communicate that way. You have different customs and your gestures mean different things so that won’t work either, but you need to know if these people are feeling joy at seeing you, peace, or mean to make war on you. Music may have evolved to serve this purpose…to communicate feeling and intent. If the war drums beat then you knew to prepare for battle. If the village burst into happy, upbeat melodies you knew to prepare a feast. If a lone messenger sang out a slow, lilting melody you knew to send an ambassador for peaceful negotiation. Maybe music evolved to function in this way…like emotocons of the past. Music was certainly used in ritual ceremonies to create a prayerful environment, to mourn, to celebrate, to dance, but always to communicate thoughts that go beyond words. In that way it is a sort of universal language. Which begs the question “Were our brains already made for music, to communicate through melody as the birds do, and we merely developed that sense further?” or “Did the need for a universal communication imprint itself on our physiology, the most successful communicators outliving others and growing the aptitude for universal musical communication into the human species?” I have no idea, but it’s worth thinking about.
It’s also worth thinking about the power music has, if it is such a base part of us. If our emotions and intentions are clearly communicated to others depending on what we listen to or the music we make, then we may have a responsibility to be as careful with our melodies as we are with our words if we are to be purposeful about communicating ideas. Although if you were with someone who had amusia it wouldn’t make any difference.
You can take an amusia test here http://www.delosis.com/listening/home.html
